Woody Tobacco vs Tobacco Vanille
Dossier vs Tom Ford
Dossier's Woody Tobacco, its Replica Jazz Club interpretation, is citrus and rum with dried fruit over styrax, tobacco and vanilla. Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille is tobacco, ginger, tonka, vanilla, cocoa and dried fruit.
| Woody Tobacco | Tobacco Vanille | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Dossier | Tom Ford |
| Concentration | EDT | EDP |
| Gender | unisex | unisex |
| Top Notes | lemon, pink pepper, neroli | — |
| Heart Notes | rum, dry fruits, blond woods | — |
| Base Notes | styrax, tobacco leaves, vanilla | — |
| Notes | — | tobacco leaf, ginger, spicy notes, tonka bean, vanilla, cocoa, dry fruit accord, sweet wood sap |
| Best Seasons | fall, winter | fall, winter |
Shared Notes (1)
Notes that appear in both fragrances
What Wearers Say
Dossier Woody Tobacco
One wearer enjoys its rum, dry vanilla-tobacco and woody impression, with citrus balancing the fruitiness.
Another wearer likes its wintry combination of tobacco, pepper and liquor-like notes.
One daily wearer finds the opening strongly alcoholic before enjoying the fruit and rum that follow.
Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille
One wearer enjoys the spicy opening followed by tobacco, powdery vanilla and cocoa.
Another wearer loves its warm, sweet tobacco-and-vanilla character for special occasions in colder weather.
Some wearers find the sweetness excessive or sickly.
The Verdict
Tobacco Vanille is our pick if it's the one you want, because Woody Tobacco is Dossier's take on Margiela's Jazz Club. They share tobacco leaves, dried fruit and vanilla, but Dossier adds lemon, pink pepper and neroli on top, rum and blond woods in the middle and styrax underneath. Rum and citrus make it brighter and boozier. Tom Ford's ginger, cocoa and tonka make it darker and closer to pipe tobacco. Choose Woody Tobacco for the bar rather than the study.
Dossier Woody Tobacco