Woody Tobacco vs Replica Jazz Club
Dossier vs Maison Margiela
Dossier's Woody Tobacco is its named Replica Jazz Club interpretation. Both list pink pepper, lemon and neroli, rum, styrax, tobacco leaf and vanilla; Margiela adds clary sage and vetiver, Dossier dried fruit and blond woods.
| Woody Tobacco | Replica Jazz Club | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Dossier | Maison Margiela |
| Concentration | EDT | EDT |
| Gender | unisex | masculine |
| Top Notes | lemon, pink pepper, neroli | pink pepper, Primofiore lemon, neroli |
| Heart Notes | rum, dry fruits, blond woods | rum, clary sage, Java vetiver |
| Base Notes | styrax, tobacco leaves, vanilla | styrax resin, tobacco leaf, vanilla bean |
| Best Seasons | fall, winter | fall, winter |
Shared Notes (3)
Notes that appear in both fragrances
What Wearers Say
Dossier Woody Tobacco
One wearer enjoys its rum, dry vanilla-tobacco and woody impression, with citrus balancing the fruitiness.
Another wearer likes its wintry combination of tobacco, pepper and liquor-like notes.
One daily wearer finds the opening strongly alcoholic before enjoying the fruit and rum that follow.
Maison Margiela Replica Jazz Club
Some wearers enjoy the warm mix of rum, tobacco and vanilla.
One wearer likes how the dry tobacco balances the sweetness as the rum and vanilla become smoother.
Some wearers want more projection or staying power.
Some find the tobacco ashy or stale rather than comforting.
The Verdict
Woody Tobacco is our pick. Dossier names Jazz Club as the reference, and the two lists are nearly the same. Both open on pink pepper, lemon and neroli and close on styrax, tobacco leaf and vanilla, with rum in the middle. The one difference is beside the rum: Margiela has clary sage and vetiver, Dossier dried fruit and blond woods. That makes Woody Tobacco a little sweeter and fruitier, and Jazz Club a little drier and greener. For a fraction of the price, that's an easy trade.
Maison Margiela Replica Jazz Club