Woody Sage vs Y
Dossier vs Yves Saint Laurent
This is a classic designer-vs-dupe showdown, with Dossier's Woody Sage claiming to recreate YSL Y's fresh sage and cedar blend at less than half the price.
| Woody Sage | Y | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Dossier | Yves Saint Laurent |
| Concentration | EDP | EDP |
| Gender | masculine | masculine |
| Price Range | $25-35 | $75-95 |
| Top Notes | bergamot, apple, ginger, aldehydes | bergamot, apple, ginger, aldehydes |
| Heart Notes | sage, juniper berries, geranium | juniper berries, sage, geranium |
| Base Notes | cedarwood, vetiver, amberwood, olibanum | cedarwood, vetiver, amberwood, olibanum |
| Best Seasons | spring, summer, fall | spring, summer, fall |
Shared Notes (11)
Notes that appear in both fragrances
What People Say
Dossier Woody Sage
No community sentiment data yet
Yves Saint Laurent Y
The bergamot and apple opening creates a crisp, professional freshness that works perfectly in office environments
Amberwood in the base gives it a warm, woody backbone that prevents it from being just another citrus fragrance
The apple note can smell synthetic and candy-like, especially in the first hour
Becomes quite linear after the opening, with minimal development throughout the day
Longevity: 6-8 hours, settles close to skin after 4 hours
Value: Decent value for a designer fragrance, though the synthetic quality shows at this price point
The Verdict
YSL Y offers superior projection and longevity with more refined blending, justifying the premium for special occasions or daily office wear. Dossier's version delivers 80% of the experience at 35% of the cost, making it perfect for casual wear or testing the scent profile before investing in the original.
Dossier Woody Sage
Yves Saint Laurent Y