Supremacy Not Only Intense vs Pegasus

Afnan vs Parfums de Marly

Afnan's Supremacy Not Only Intense is widely known as a clone of Parfums de Marly Pegasus, so the obvious question is whether the $20 bottle is close enough to skip the $300 splurge.

Supremacy Not Only Intense Pegasus
Brand Afnan Parfums de Marly
Concentration EDP EDP
Gender masculine masculine
Price Range $20-35 $175-320
Top Notes bergamot, lavender, apple, cardamom bergamot, lavender, apple
Heart Notes heliotrope, jasmine, geranium, iris heliotrope, jasmine, geranium
Base Notes sandalwood, vanilla, white musk, ambergris sandalwood, vanilla, white musk, ambergris
Best Seasons spring, fall, winter fall, winter, spring

Shared Notes (10)

Notes that appear in both fragrances

bergamot lavender apple heliotrope jasmine geranium sandalwood vanilla white musk ambergris

The Verdict

If you just want the vibe — creamy sandalwood, powdery heliotrope, soft vanilla — the Afnan gets you 80% of the way there for a fraction of the cost, making it a no-brainer for casual wear or testing the waters. But Pegasus wins on refinement, longevity, and that intangible smoothness that justifies the price for special occasions or fragrance enthusiasts who'll notice the difference. Buy the Afnan first; upgrade to Pegasus only if it leaves you wanting more.

Afnan Supremacy Not Only Intense