Club de Nuit Sillage vs Silver Mountain Water
Armaf vs Creed
Both open with citrus and blackcurrant. Silver Mountain Water turns to tea and an ozonic accord; Club de Nuit Sillage turns to violet leaf, iris, florals and ambroxan.
| Club de Nuit Sillage | Silver Mountain Water | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Armaf | Creed |
| Concentration | EDP | EDP |
| Gender | unisex | unisex |
| Top Notes | bergamot, lemon, lime, ginger, blackcurrant, violet leaves | bergamot, blackcurrant, galbanum, orange |
| Heart Notes | jasmine, iris, rose | tea, ozonic accord |
| Base Notes | sandalwood, cedar wood, musk, ambroxan | musk, sandalwood |
| Best Seasons | spring, summer, fall | spring, summer, fall |
Shared Notes (4)
Notes that appear in both fragrances
What Wearers Say
Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage
A wearer enjoys the citrusy, metallic freshness; another likes it despite usually disliking citrus notes.
A commenter who likes the fragrance still finds it somewhat synthetic-smelling.
Creed Silver Mountain Water
One sampler enjoys its sweet, soapy cleanliness.
Some wearers particularly enjoy an inky, aquatic or metallic impression.
One wearer finds the opening the best part and wishes the scent lasted longer.
Another skin tester finds the fruity aspect sour and unpleasant.
The Verdict
Silver Mountain Water is our pick for its clarity: bergamot, blackcurrant and green, sharp galbanum over tea and an ozonic accord make it smell cold and clean, like snowmelt. Sillage shares the citrus and blackcurrant but swaps the tea for violet leaf, ginger and iris, which is where its metallic, slightly powdery edge comes from, and adds jasmine, rose and ambroxan. It's a different take rather than a copy. Choose Sillage if you want more florals and a fraction of the price.
Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage