All My Girls vs Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait
Alexandria Fragrances vs Maison Francis Kurkdjian
These two share nearly identical DNA — All My Girls is literally inspired by Baccarat Rouge 540 — so the real question is how much that difference in quality and concentration is worth to you.
| All My Girls | Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Alexandria Fragrances | Maison Francis Kurkdjian |
| Concentration | EDP | Parfum |
| Gender | unisex | unisex |
| Price Range | $30-50 | $400-500 |
| Top Notes | saffron, jasmine, bitter almond | saffron, jasmine, bitter almond |
| Heart Notes | amberwood, ambergris, cedarwood | amberwood, fir resin, cedar |
| Base Notes | fir resin, musk, sandalwood | ambergris, musk, oakmoss |
| Best Seasons | fall, winter, spring | fall, winter, spring |
Shared Notes (7)
Notes that appear in both fragrances
What People Say
Alexandria Fragrances All My Girls
No community sentiment data yet
Maison Francis Kurkdjian Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait
The extrait takes the EDP's already iconic jasmine-saffron-amberwood accord and renders it denser and more resinous — the sweetness feels crystallized rather than syrupy, which is the key distinction fans point to.
Projection on the extrait is genuinely nuclear in the opening hours; the ambergris and amberwood combination radiates off the skin in a way that fills a room without smelling loud or aggressive.
At $400-500, you're paying a steep premium over the EDP for what many find to be a marginal real-world difference — the DNA is identical and casual wearers rarely notice the concentration gap.
The jasmine-amberwood-musk combo has been cloned so aggressively by drugstore and designer houses alike that wearing the original now reads as generic to anyone who pays attention to fragrance, which is a genuinely bizarre fate for the actual source.
Longevity: 12+ hours is commonly reported; the dry-down phase can persist as a close skin scent well beyond that
Value: The extrait is harder to justify than the EDP unless the resinous depth and longevity bump genuinely matter to you — most of the community considers the EDP the better value entry point for the same effect
The Verdict
If you're curious about the BR540 hype without the heart attack price tag, All My Girls gets you surprisingly close for under $50. But if you want the full experience — deeper projection, richer resinous complexity, and that almost crystalline extrait intensity — the MFK is worth the splurge for serious fragrance lovers. The clone is a great daily driver; the original is an occasion fragrance.
Alexandria Fragrances All My Girls
Maison Francis Kurkdjian Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait